The Best Starting Words for Word Detective, Tested on Every Answer

Most advice about five-letter word puzzles is based on general English. Word Detective uses its own list of 686 answer words, so we measured the starters against that list directly. For every valid opening word with five different letters (3,124 of them), we played it against all 686 answers using the game’s own colouring rules and counted how many answers were still possible afterwards.

The result is a ranking you can actually use, plus a few facts about the answer list that are worth knowing before you type your first guess.

How we measured a “good” starter

A first guess is useful when it splits the 686 possible answers into lots of small groups. If the tiles come back teal, grey, amber, grey, grey, only the answers that would produce exactly that colouring are left. A good starter makes that leftover group small on average, whatever the answer turns out to be.

So for each starter we worked out the expected number of answers remaining after it: the average size of the group you land in. Lower is better. We also counted how many different colour patterns the word can produce, because more patterns means finer splits.

The ranking

How well each starting word narrows down the 686 Word Detective answers
Starting wordAnswers left on averageDifferent patternsRank of 3,124
CRATE15.91203
TRACE16.11214
ORATE15.91031
IRATE15.91022
RAISE16.81005
ARISE16.9956
STARE17.81088
CRANE18.511311
SLATE18.910813
ADIEU38.459920
AUDIO57.1632,097

ORATE, IRATE and CRATE are effectively tied at about 16 answers left. CRATE and TRACE produce the most distinct patterns, so they’re slightly more likely to leave you with a very small group. Any word in the top ten is an excellent choice, and the differences between them are smaller than the difference a good second guess makes.

Why vowel-heavy starters disappoint

ADIEU and AUDIO are popular because they test four vowels at once. On this answer list they’re poor openers: after ADIEU you’re left with about 38 possible answers on average, more than twice as many as after CRATE. After AUDIO it’s 57.

The reason is simple. Almost every answer contains a vowel, so learning which vowels it has tells you less than you’d think. Common consonants such as R, T, C and S split the list far more evenly. The best starters combine one or two strong vowels (A and E) with the most common consonants.

What the 686 answers look like

Here’s the share of answers that contain each letter at least once:

Most common letters in Word Detective answers
LetterAnswers containing it
E47.5%
A42.7%
R39.9%
T30.9%
O28.9%
L28.4%
I28.3%
S27.3%
C22.9%
N22.6%

At the other end, J, Q, X and Z each appear in fewer than 2% of answers. Don’t spend early guesses on them.

Position matters too:

  • First letter: S is by far the most common (15.9% of answers), followed by C (9.5%), P and B (7.1% each).
  • Second letter: O (14.0%), R (13.1%), A (12.0%) and L (10.3%). Many answers start with a consonant pair such as ST-, SH-, CH-, GR-, BR- or CL-.
  • Last letter: E ends 20.8% of answers, then T (13.4%), Y (10.3%), R (9.5%) and H (7.7%).
  • Endings: the most common last two letters are -ER (38 answers), -CH (26), -ST (21), -CK (19), -SE (19) and -LE (18).

Tip: more than one answer in four (194 of 686, or 28.3%) repeats a letter, as in SALAD, TRUST, SPEED or STILL. If you’re running out of new letters, try a repeat.

A worked example

Suppose the hidden word is GRAIN. Here’s how a CRATE opener plays out, with the number of possible answers after each guess:

CRATE 9 answers left: BRAIN, BRAND, DRAIN, DRAMA, GRAIN, GRAND, GRAPH, GRASS and GRAVY.

Nine candidates share _RA__. Rather than guessing one of them at random, pick a word that tests the letters that separate them. GRAND checks G (first letter of five candidates) as well as N and D:

GRAND 1 answer left: G, R and A are in place, N is in the word but not fifth, and there’s no D. Only GRAIN fits.

GRAIN Solved in three.

Even an all-grey first row is useful. If the answer is SOUND, CRATE comes back completely grey, which still cuts 686 answers to 41: you now know the word has no C, R, A, T or E.

Two-word openings

If you like to play the same two words every day, ORATE followed by CLIPS is the strongest pair we found among second words that use five new letters: together they leave about 2.1 answers on average. CHILD (2.2) and CLING (2.3) are close behind. A fixed pair is easy to remember, but choosing your second guess based on the first row’s colours, as in the GRAIN example, is usually better.

Five habits that save guesses

  1. Use your second guess to test new letters, not to repeat the ones you already know. A teal letter is already found; you don’t need to spend a slot confirming it.
  2. Never put an amber letter back in the same spot. Amber means “in the word, but not here”.
  3. Watch out for word families. BATCH, CATCH, HATCH, LATCH, MATCH, PATCH and WATCH are all answers. If you have _ATCH with three guesses left, guessing them one by one can fail. A word like CLAMP tests C, L, M and P together.
  4. Read grey repeats carefully. If you guess a word with two Es and one turns grey, the answer has exactly one E.
  5. Save hints for the end. The daily word has two free hints, each revealing a letter in place. They’re most valuable when you’re down to a few close candidates.

Word Detective has one daily word that’s the same for everyone, and unlimited practice words for trying out new openers without affecting your streak.

Try it nowPlay Word Detective free in your browser, no sign-up needed.
Play Word Detective